« The role of a story in lessons learning | Main | Adding storytelling to the employee engagement agenda »
| 22/01/08 | | World Trade Center and emergency services mis-coordination |
One tragic example [of mis-coordination] is recounted in Peter Denning’s article about HFN [hastily formed networks], in which he describes analysis of the disaster response efforts after the attack on the World Trade Center: New York Police Department (NYPD) helicopters that had been monitoring conditions by circling the towers had observed signs of structural collapse in the north tower and immediately issued an emergency evacuation order to all police; however, they failed to inform the firefighters, who, having had no warning, were not evacuated.
Huston, Tracey. "Enabling Adaptability & Innovation through Hastily Formed Networks." Reflections 7, no. 1 (2006): 9-29.
Email this entry to a friend
View the Technorati Link Cosmos for this entry
Comments
As I understand it, it wasn't that the police didn't inform the firefighters, but that they were unable to do so promptly because they operated different communication systems.
The police knew of the firefighter presence on the higher floors (over a hundred of them were resting on one floor when the collapse happened and had been spotted by a police helicopter). But by the time the messages had gone back to their own despatcher and across to the firefighters' despatcher, it was too late.
This is one of the lasting bitternesses of the New York firefighters against Rudy Giuliani. After the 1993 attack, there were several attempts to get a common radio system across the emergency response services but budgets were not released. The firefighters finally got a new (incompatible) system just before 911, and it was famous for its lack of reliability even without the need to coordinate with other services.
Posted by: Patrick Lambe at January 23, 2008 7:40 PM
Thanks for expanding on what happened Patrick.
Posted by: Shawn Callahan at January 24, 2008 8:40 AM