« Why people don't use collaboration tools |
Main
| Distributed teams and the bane of time zones »
John F. Kennedy and the French Revolution
Posted by Shawn Callahan - 16/06/07
Filed in Anecdotes.
Filed in Anecdotes.
I heard this anecdote last week.
John Kennedy was meeting the Premier of China and during some initial small talk Kennedy asked the Premier what he thought of the French Revolution. The Premier replied, “it's probably too early to say.”







Comments
The French have made so many great things ever since - and so many mistakes - that the Chinese Premer comment is meaningless.
Posted by: avi at June 17, 2007 8:33 PM
I thought this anecdote was a comment on how the Chinese saw the long-term view.
Posted by: Shawn at June 17, 2007 9:40 PM
My interpretation is similar. The Chinese vision of their civilization covers thousands of years, where as ours covers only three centuries. The story made me reflect on our society - the instant gratification demands plus demands for innovations and change to be evaluated even before they are adequately developed. Thanks for the story.
Posted by: John Parboosingh at June 18, 2007 2:12 AM
I like that anecdote, but I suspect that it never happened - not with JFK at least. The US didn't officially recognise the People's Republic of China until after Kennedy was asassinated. The first US President to meet the Chinese Premier was Nixon, I think. Hence the US phrase "Only Nixon could go to China".
Posted by: Ben at June 20, 2007 9:27 AM
Thanks Ben for putting this through the mythbusters test.
Posted by: Shawn at June 20, 2007 12:31 PM
Shawn,
I really liked this anecdote. Whether the facts were correct or not did not affect the knowledge being imparted to me: Culture and time perspective....the point was so beautifully stated in a few words. More importantly, it reminds me that facts in storytelling have less value than the contextual meaning. Each listener will filter the story thru their own experience and spin their own meaning. That meaning is what we will listen for...
Posted by: Gloria Fox at June 22, 2007 5:18 AM
I think this statement is more likely to reflect communist doctrine than anything else. Similar to Krushiev' misunderstood "We will bury you," it should be interpretted in the context of the marxist view that revolution of the proletariat and eventual conversion to communism is inevitabble.
Posted by: Ford Harding at July 9, 2007 1:37 AM
BBC NEWS on a page referenced by Wikipedia for their Zhou_Enlai summary, attributes the quote to Zhou.
Posted by: Jack at August 5, 2008 10:09 AM
Post a comment