Subscribe
« Home Comforts not Sun Tzu |
Main
| Share a story - March of Dimes story »
Developing your narrative competence
Posted by - 3/11/05
Filed in .
Filed in .
Shawn recently blogged an interesting post on how to develop your narrative competence. The value of a developed sense of narrative competence is well recognised in the Medical field.
Here’s an interesting one for pictorial narratives*.
Do you think the figures below are both narratives?
(*- From “Narrative Representation to Narrative Use: Towards the Limits of Definition – NARRATIVE, Vol. 13, No. 2 (May 2005)”)
Send this entry to: 
Comments
I was expecting a few comments on this one, so, I might as well make that expectation come true. :)
The answer of whether the two figures are narrative comes down to: 'it depends'.
Most people will have no problems seeing the Calvin and Hobbes figure as a narrative, it is the second one, which reads more like instructions which is challenging. However, it is possible to consider in several thousand years a team of archeologists discovering this picture and 'reading as' as narrative of how an ancient civilization put alot of effort and work into building a special object....
The point I guess is that 'it depends' on what the point of the narrative is for, what is its use.
Regards,
Andrew
Posted by: Andrew Rixon at November 6, 2005 10:44 AM
On the other hand, if you had never seen a cartoon strip before, the Calvin & Hobbes might be mystifying.
Do you go from left to write or write to left? Is this one snapshot in time showing four quadruplets?
Picture systems have a grammar of their own...
Posted by: Matt Moore at November 7, 2005 5:28 PM
Post a comment